The roar of the Yankee Stadium crowd often carries the weight of history, a constant reminder of the legends who have donned the pinstripes. This season, all eyes are on Aaron Judge, the towering outfielder whose prodigious power and charismatic presence have cemented his place as the modern face of the franchise. But is 2025 the year he truly begins to overshadow the legacy of another complex but undeniably impactful Yankee slugger, Alex Rodriguez?
As the calendar turned to May, and the early chapters of the 2025 MLB season unfolded, the numbers began to tell a compelling story. Through the initial weeks of the campaign, Aaron Judge has continued his torrid pace, already launching 10 home runs in just 31 games. This consistent power surge has brought him to a career total of 325 home runs in a Yankees uniform.
While still shy of Alex Rodriguez’s 351 homers hit during his tumultuous but often brilliant tenure in the Bronx, the trajectory is undeniable. Judge possesses the rare ability to go on sustained power streaks, evidenced by his remarkable seasons of 52 (2017), 62 (2022), and 58 (2024). If he maintains a similar pace throughout the remainder of 2025, it’s highly conceivable that he will surpass A-Rod’s mark, etching his name even higher in the Yankees’ home run annals. The anticipation among fans is palpable – will the Judge’s gavel strike down another piece of Yankees history this year?
Intriguingly, one significant milestone has already been quietly achieved. With 1,076 hits as a Yankee, Aaron Judge has already surpassed Alex Rodriguez’s total of 1,056 hits in pinstripes. While perhaps not as attention-grabbing as the home run chase, this accomplishment speaks to Judge’s consistent offensive production and his growing body of work in the Bronx.
However, the comparison to A-Rod extends beyond just home runs and hits. In terms of RBIs, Judge currently trails significantly, with 748 compared to Rodriguez’s formidable 1,086. While Judge’s career-high of 144 RBIs in 2024 showcases his ability to drive in runs, the sheer volume needed to eclipse A-Rod in this category within a single season makes it a highly improbable feat for 2025. Similarly, in games played, Judge’s 1,024 appearances fall short of Rodriguez’s 1,256. Surpassing this mark would require Judge to remain a fixture in the lineup for at least two more full seasons, highlighting the longevity of A-Rod’s Yankees career.
Therefore, the narrative of 2025 as the year Aaron Judge leaves Alex Rodriguez behind in Yankees history is a nuanced one. He has already eclipsed A-Rod in career hits, a testament to his consistent offensive output. The possibility of him surpassing A-Rod in career home runs as a Yankee looms large and could very well become a reality by season’s end, adding another thrilling chapter to Judge’s already storied Yankees career.
However, the broader picture reveals that catching A-Rod in categories like RBIs and games played remains a longer-term prospect. Yet, as Aaron Judge continues to solidify his legacy in the Bronx, 2025 stands as a pivotal year – the year he definitively surpassed one significant offensive mark and stands on the precipice of potentially eclipsing another, further cementing his place among the Yankee greats and inviting inevitable comparisons to the stars of the franchise’s rich past. The echoes of the bat and the roar of the crowd will undoubtedly tell the ongoing story of Aaron Judge’s ascent in Yankees history.
Be the first to comment